Friday, April 28, 2017

Memo to PM on appointment of Lokpal from OSAA


Dear friends

During week-long Anti-corruption Campaign organised  by Odisha Soochana Adhikar Abhijan in 23 districts of Odisha from 1st to 7th April 2017, we have undertaken signature campaign    to build up public opinion  and generate public demand for immediate constitution of Lokpal at Centre.  Hundreds of the people joining in our campaign have supported our drive by signing memorandum  addressed to Prime Minister, India  for constitution of Lokayukta at centre.  This memorandum has already been despatched  to Prime Minister’ office on 24.4.17.  The text of Memorandum is  presented below for Readers’ reference.

Regards
Pradip Pradhan
State Convener
M-9937843482

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Memorandum to Shri Narendra Modi Prime Minister of India for convening the meeting of Lokpal Selection Committee for long awaited institution of Lokpal at Centre

To
Shri Narendra Modi, Prime Minister of India, New Delhi

SUB: Request for convening the Meeting of Lokpal Selection Committee for instituting of long awaited Lokpal at the Centre

Dear Prime Minister,

We, the  following  signatories, joining in Anti-Corruption Campaign Organized by Odisha Soochana Adhikar Abhijan through out the State from 1st April to 7th April, 2017 bring to your kind notice the following matter seeking your judicious action.

Well aware as you are, the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act 2013, the premier anticorruption law which provides for setting up watchdog bodies like Lokpal at Centre and Lokayuktas in States, was enacted by Parliament in response to a strident country-wide people’s movement that demanded the institution of such bodies forthwith to free the nation from an all-pervasive menace of corruption. The Act was duly notified in Official Gazette on 1st January 2014 and had come into force on 16th January 2014. Thereafter the series of Rules concerning Lokpal Selection Committee and Search Committee and also Disclosure of Assets and Liabilities by Public Servants have also been made and are in place. But, it is a matter of great anguish that the people of the country feel utterly shocked and betrayed for the glaring failure of the present Government at Centre to set up Lokpal despite a long lapse of more than 3 years from the enforcement of the Act and Rules.

Moreover, in absence of a Lokpal at the Centre and taking this excuse, different State Governments including Odisha who had passed their respective Lokayukta Bills albeit in a haphazard manner, have been showing their reluctance to go ahead for setting up Lokayuktas after effecting proper amendment to the hurriedly passed defective Bills. Thus, the institution of Lokayuktas in States does also decisively depend on the institution of Lokpal at Centre.  

As you know too well, it is none else than the Prime Minister himself who is the prime mover to set the entire process of instituting of Lokpal at the Centre into motion, since he happens to be the ex-officio Chairman of Lokpal Selection Committee. But, to the best of our knowledge, the PM has not called any single meeting of this august Committee till date, letting thereby the whole issue of instituting Lokpal at Centre hang fire, to the utter surprise and anguish of the whole nation who had wholeheartedly fought for it in not too distant past.  

You are therefore earnestly requested to initiate the process of instituting Lokpal at Centre, by calling the meeting of Lokpal Selection Committee at the earliest, and thereby pave the way for proper operationalization of Lokayuktas in States across the country.


Signature of the people joined in Anti-corruption Campaign organised by OSAA in 23 districts of Odisha



Thursday, April 27, 2017

NGOs- funded for Peoples’ Bio-diversity Registers in Odisha and Dillydallying by OBB

NGOs- funded  for Peoples’ Bio-diversity Registers in Odisha and  Dillydallying by OBB 

Dear friends

RTI Application was submitted  to the PIO, office of Odisha Biodiversity Board (OBB)  under Department of  Forest and Environment, Govt. of Odisha  seeking  some iformation about  preparation of Bio-diversity Registers in Odisha. On 21.4.17, the PIO has provided  the following  information.  The PIO  has tried  to   cover up  many issues  by providing  misleading  information  which will be   challenged  through appeal procedure under RTI Act.  It   has been outlined below.

A.                 Provide name of the organisations which have been sanctioned funds for preparation of people’s Biodiversity Registers  (PBR) by State Bio-diversity Board (year-wise)
Year
Name of NGO
Total fund sanctioned
Total amount spent
2013-17
M/s Swaminathan Research Foundation ( MSSRF), Jeypore
3,78,000
3,78,000
2015-17
Grama Swaraj, Baripada
4,95,000
4,95,000
2015-17
NIRMAN, BBSR
3,60,000
3,60,000
2015-17
SAPNA, BBSR
1,70,000
1,70,000
2016-17
PAHAD, Phulbai
1,44,000
1,44,000
2016-17
APOWA, Kendrapara
90,000
90,000
2016-17
SEWAK, Sundargarh
54,000
54,000
2016-17
CARD, Ganjam
54.000
54,000
2016-17
CSRD, Cuttack
11,70,000
11,70,000
2017
LIPICA, Gajapati
18,000
18,000

Total
36,05,375
36,05,375

B.                 Provide name of the NGOs who have not  yet completed the project sanctioned to them  and reason thereof.

Response of PIO
The PIO  has responded  that all abovementioned organisations  have not yet completed  PBR. But  the PIO  has given very confusing reply  about reasons.  He has mentioned  that

“ the Draft  PBRs submitted by  abovementioned NGOs are being evaluated  regularly  by an evaluation committee of OBB   and necessary  modifications  are being suggested  to them. After incorporating the corrections, the drafts are again submitted to OBB for evaluation  and this process continues  till the NGOs submit error free drafts.

Comments:
The PIO should  mention details of  the procedure  for  monitoring or evaluation of the project by PBB. But he has not clearly mentioned details of the reasons for non-completion of the project by NGOs.

C.                 Provide name of  NGOs  which  have not been   released complete sanctioned amount till yet and reason thereof including  copy of the file noting.  If the Govt. has sought any query or compliance or explanation from them, please provide  copy of it.

Response of PIO:
The PIO has not provided  any information  but cited  above mentioned  information   which is reproduced  by me “ the Draft  PBRs submitted by  abovementioned NGOs are being evaluated  regularly  by an evaluation committee of OBB   and necessary  modifications  are being suggested  to them. After incorporating the corrections, the drafts are again submitted to OBB for evaluation  and this process continues  till the NGOs submit error free drafts.

Comments: The PIO has   tried to keep the information secret.  The PIO could have   cited reason for non-release of fund.  The PIO could have provided copy of query or explanation sought from NGOs.  I think, this Board has tried its best to harass NGOs citing so-called reasons for non-release of fund.

D.                 Provide details of evaluation of the project sanctioned to the NGOs, if any made  by SBB. Name of the evaluators  with their address. 

Response of PIO:  As mentioned earlier,  the draft PBRs submitted  by NGOs are evaluated by  Committee. The details are enclosed  as Annexture-II.

Comments :  I have wanted  details of evaluation made  by PBB. It means any evaluation conducted or not. If conducted, the report should be provided.  But the PIO  has provided  a  copy of office order  about constitution of  5-member evaluation Committee on 12.1.15. It means Evaluation Committee has not conducted  a single project since last 2  and half years.  This is tragedy  how Biodiversity Board is functioning in Odisha  since last five years of its functioning.

· NGOs are not properly supported.
· No monitoring and evaluation of the project  is conducted  properly.
· Fund is not released properly.
· Over all it can be said, Odisha Bio-diversity Board has failed in all respects.


 Pradip Pradhan
M-9937843482
Date- 27.4.17


Nabin Patnaik, Chief Minister- Giant Killer of Children in Odisha

Nabin Patnaik, Chief Minister- Giant Killer of Children in Odisha

Dear friends

A child is the future of country. The life of a Child has been safeguarded by starting from Indian Constitution to United Nation’s Convention on Rights of Child. To save the children from vulnerability, malnutrition and hunger, the National Govt.  has launched ICDS  programme from 1973   with required budgetary allocation in each year   to all states  to ensure  nutritious food  to  the  children  along  with provision of  other  services like immunisation, free health  check up, pr-schooling, referral service etc. through Anganwadi Centres.  Full-fledged Anganwadi centres with availability of all infrastructures is pre-requisite to render ICDS service to the Children of age group of 7 months to 6 years.   While hearing WP(C ) No. 196/2001, the Supreme Court  has  given   series of directions to both Central Government   and State Government  to streamline  ICDS programme including developing infrastructure  like own building  and other accessories for  each Anganwadi Centres. The Central Govt.  has also made huge financial allocation to State Govt.  for construction of   building of the AWCs. 

 Within 18 years of rule in Odisha as Chief Minister, Nabin Patnaik has claimed of taking a lot of measures including Mamata Yojana to check child malnutrition and child death in the state.  But we do not see any substantial changes in reduction of child malnutrition death in the state.  Despite huge allocation and expenditure of fund for ICDS programme and distribution of egg and Chhatua  to the beneficiaries, ICDS project  has miserably  failed  to   check child malnutrition  in Odisha mostly in tribal pockets.  To cover up child malnutrition issue, many times the state Govt. attributes  the reason of child death   is   unknown disease , sometimes  lack of treatment  etc.

But the major challenge  the Anganwadi workers  face  while  carrying out multiple  activity under ICDS project is lack of infrastructure i.e., own building.  As per  the information obtained  under RTI  on 31.3.2017  from Dept. of Women and Child Development, Govt. of Odisha,  55 % of Anganwadi Centre do not  have own building in Odisha. Due to  absence of  own building , the Aganwadi workers are  seen gathering  the children in open field or  under tree or someone’s verandah.  children are not only served  food properly but also  deprived of  immunisation and pre-school education. The  ill-trained  and illiterate Anganwadi workers  conduct their office work in their  house and hardly  visits centres. Besides  that  the huge  corruption,  misappropriation of fund , distribution of  low quality Chhatua  has marred  ICDS programme  in tribal pockets.

  The question comes why Nabin Patnaik Govt.   precariously failed  to ensure  building  to all Centres within 18 years of rule in the state.   The reason cited by State Govt.   as non-availability of fund   is big hoax. Because the special untied fund is given by Central Govt.  under various schemes like IAP, Tribal sub-plan schemes, NREGA  etc.  which  could have been used  to  develop infrastructure  for AWCs. MPLAD, MLAD LAD  of BJD MPs and MLAs  could have been used  to develop infrastructure.  But  this Govt.  has failed  in all respects.  Lack of transparency,  mis-governance  and Maladministration and corruption  perpetuated  by Nabin Patnaik  has  brought down economic development of the state and resulted in big failure of ICDS project in Odisha.

Status of Own Building of Anganwadi Centres in Odisha
Sl.No
Name of District
Sanctioned
Own Building as on 31.12.2016
Anganwadi Centres
Mini-AWCs
Total
1
Angul
1622
32
1654
939
2
Balasore
3687
480
4167
1055
3
Baragarh
2670
229
2899
1116
4
Bhadrak
2166
269
2435
849
5
Bolangir
2472
188
2660
1496
6
Boudh
650
67
717
450
7
Cuttack
2992
326
3318
770
8
Deogarh
572
216
788
514
9
Dhenkanal
1873
327
2200
1381
10
Gajapati
1451
924
2375
894
11
Ganjam
5073
66
5139
1735
12
Jagatsingh Pur
1647
193
1840
525
13
Jajpur
2760
46
2806
717
14
Jharsuguda
786
171
957
664
15
Kalahandi
1837
410
2247
1411
16
Kandhamal
1580
522
2102
1364
17
Kendrapara
1883
264
2147
446
18
Keonjhar
2512
745
3257
1889
19
Khurda
2409
145
2554
747
20
Koraput
2723
541
3264
1617
21
Malkangiri
1020
230
1250
1050
22
Mayurbhanj
3680
1200
4880
3041
23
Nawarangpur
2038
181
2219
1495
24
Nayagarh
1169
415
1584
447
25
Nuapara
1216
140
1356
970
26
Puri
2560
39
2599
607
27
Rayagada
1397
550
1947
962
28
Sambalpur
1466
380
1846
1368
29
Subarnpur
1250
321
1571
694
30
Sundargarh
3010
799
3809
2351

Total
62171
10416
72587
33564

Sanjay Sahu, RTI Activist
Core-Committee Member of Odisha Soochana Adhikar Abhijan
M- 86416694

Date- 28.4.17