Judgement Brief of The latest Supreme Court of India Judgment delivered only on
Dated 26-10-2026.
This Judgement is very important after Thalappalam case:
- Case Title:-The Muppathdam Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. -Vs -State Chief Information Commissioner & Ors.
- Case Number:- Supreme Court - Civil Appeal No. 13907/2026[ @ SLP(C) 12846/2025 & 13906/2026,]
- Decided on Dated: 26-10-2026
- Division Bench:- Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran.
Author: Justice K. Vinod Chandran
5. Citation Nu: 2026 INSC 1153 : 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 1085 - Decided 26.10.2026.
Facts Leading to the case:-
Applicant (the 4th respondent) is a Member of the Muppathdam Service Co-op Bank, Ltd. Kerala. He Filed RTI Application to Joint Registrar (General), Co-op Societies [2nd Respondent - public authority] asking for 2 documents as given below-
(1) Copy of Construction Agreement between Appellant Bank and a Labour Co-operative Society for building construction
(2). Copy of Minutes of last General Body Meeting of the Bank.
- The PIO denied the information.
Bank argued that "We are not public authority under Section 2(h) of the Act as per Thalappalam Service Co-op Bank Ltd Vs State of Kerala [(2013) 16 SCC 82], hence RTI is not applicable. Registrar can access our records only after inquiry under Section 65 of Kerala Cooperative Societies Act, 1969 is initiated.
- First application was rejected upto the level of Kerala State Information Commission(SIC). Single Judge also rejected. Division Bench directed reconsideration.
- In the Second round - SIC, Single Judge and Division Bench allowed the disclosure. Being aggrieved the Bank went to Supreme Court.
6. Arguments advanced by the Bank:-
1. Not public authority - Thalappalam applies.
2. Registrar has no document in possession, cannot create.
3. Registrar can access under Sec 66 only when inspectionc deemed necessary, under Sec 65 only after inquiry ordered.
Supreme Court - Final Ratio - Appeal Dismissed:
Court did not declare the Bank as "public authority'. It decided on the basis of the definition of "information' in Section 2(f) second part:
"Information relating to the private body which can be accessed by public authority under any other law" is information under the RTI Act, 2005, even if not in physical possession of public authority."
Key Findings :-
1. Member cannot be denied on ground of personal/confidential:
"a Member of the Society cannot be denied such information on the ground that it is personal to the Society or that it does not involve any public activity or interest. Supreme Court held.
2. Registrar is public authority, and Section 66 confers supervisory powers:
"Section 66 of the Co-operative Societies Act confers supervisory powers and powers of inspection on the Registrar... which supervision includes 'an inspection of the books of the society'. We are hence, convinced that judgment of Division Bench is perfectly in order."
3. Prior inquiry NOT necessary:-
Registrar's statutory access cannot be made conditional upon prior initiation of inquiry. Access to relevant documents may itself be necessary for Registrar to determine whether inquiry is warranted._ 6c5f
4. Relied on the precedent case of CPIO, Supreme Court Vs Subhash Chandra Agarwal (2019) - "Access by public authority to private body info should not be shackled by restrictions beea"
Order:-
2nd respondent shall call for the two documents immediately and in any event within two weeks and supply same to 4th respondent."
-Far reaching the impact of the Judgement :-
Even if Co-op Bank/Society is not public authority under Thalappalam, you can file RTI to Registrar/Joint Registrar, Co-op Societies - because he can access any record under Section 66, and that record becomes "information" under Section 2(f). This is the new route after Thalappalam closed direct route.
This judgment overrules defence of Odisha/Punjab co-op societies that "we are private body, no covered under the RTI- Act".
Thank You
Prabhat Giri
Retired Civil Servant and RTI Expert
No comments:
Post a Comment