Why  do I say “5T
and Transparency in administration”  as claimed
by Chief Minister, Odisha  is big bluff ?
Dear friends 
RTI Act  which 
is implemented  in Odisha  since 2005 
is a law that  enforces   paradigm 
shift from a  colonial, secretive
, authoritarian administration  to a  Transparent 
and Accountable  Governance system
in   the 
country keeping  the  people 
at center-stage  declaring  them as Master  of the 
Country. The   governance
starting  from  office  of Rastrapati Bhawan  to 
Gram Panchayat  office  including High Court, supreme Court  and Governor house   will be
transparent  and accountable  to the 
common  people  including 
beggars, destitute , orphans, homeless of the  country. RTI Act  is 
acclaimed  as  best law 
and  occupies 3rd  position in the  ranking 
of best RTI laws   in the world. 
Since  2005, the Nabin Patnaik  Govt. and his 
coterie  of bureaucrats  have 
hatched  conspiracy  from day 
one to  destroy  this 
beautiful  law  on the 
soil of  Odisha. They  have 
tried  to dilute  implementation of RTI Act   and make it inoperative through  anti-people , absurd and illegitimate Odisha
RTI Rules, 2005 ,  keeping State  Vigilance out of purview of RTI Act and
making defunct  system of voluntary
disclosure  of information under section
4 of the Act.  Within 15  years of implementation of  RTI Act, the 
Chief Minister  has never  spoken 
a single word  about  RTI Act, though  he claims 
his Govt. as a transparent 
Govt.  The  question is 
obviously  asked  how  a
Government  will  be transparent  without  effective implementation of RTI Act , a law  which was 
especially   enacted  by Indian Parliament  to enforce transparency.
It has been proved several
times that “5T, Mo Sarkar, Zero Tolerance to Corruption, Transparent Govt.”  is all 
big lie  and designed  to deceive 
the people of  Odisha. Most of the
officers are well-trained how defy RTI Act, deny information and harass
information-seekers including life threats, permanent disable   and clod-blooded murder.  
In context of  COVID management in Odisha  , Secrecy   is very 
clearly  visible  in every 
step  of starting  COVID Testing 
to treatment of patients  to  allocation and expenditure  of fund. The 
information is consciously kept 
secret  for  covering  up  corruption and huge irregularities and  COVID mismanagement.     I 
present  here how  the 
information about  COVID
management  is denied   under RTI Act  and kept 
secret  at  the wishes 
of corrupt  bureaucracy. 
N.B.- As 
per  section 7(1)  of the RTI Act, the PIO is required  to supply 
the  information  within 30 days. 
| 
Date  of 
  RTI Application submitted  with
  name  of Dept.  | 
Subject  matter 
  of information  | 
Information supplied  or 
  denied without  citing any
  reasons  | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 4.5.20  | 
i. Minutes  of meeting of Emergency purchasing
  Committee  held  from day one after declaration of COVID
  Lockdown till 15th May, 2020 for procurement of various materials.
   
ii.  copy 
  of letter for  appointing Hemant
  Sharma  as Procurement officer  for COVID 19 and  copy of Govt. order issued  in this regard.  
iii. Copy of
  guideline/ instruction/ circular issued in respect of purchase of items  with specification  that is to be purchased  and procedure  to be followed.  
iii.  details of 
  specification of  equipment
  invited y Govt.  and copy  of 
  purchasing order  and  details of equipment already purchased  with 
  name  of the  companies 
  which  supplied.   | 
RTI Application was
  transferred to  the  Managing 
  Director, Odisha State  Medical
  Corporation Ltd.  to supply the  information.  Though two months  passed, the PIO  has not 
  supplied  any  information.  | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 24.4.20  | 
Test  conducted on COVID 19 
i. 
  date on which COVID Testing started 
  by Govt.  
ii. day-wise  no. of 
  testing  conducted , no. of  testing found negative and no. of testing
  found positive.  
iii. details of  testing 
  centres  in Odisha  in which COVID Testing  Conducted and date of functioning of the
  centres.  
iv.details of expenses made under
  different heads for COVID testing  and payment
  made . 
v. details of  financial support provided  to different  private organisations operating COVID 19
  hospitals in Odisha . 
vi.total no. of COVID hospital
  opened  and its location and  date of beginning of its  functioning and financial  support 
  provided  to each COVID
  hospital   | 
Though 3 months passed,  the Dept. has not  supplied any  information till yet . But  not 
  responded  the RTI Application.   | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 1.5.20  | 
Management of COVID Call  centre 
  and 104 no. 
i.  Name 
  of the  organization/
  Department   engaged / appointed  for over-all management of  COVID-19 
  call centres  and place  from which it operates.  
ii. Name  of the persons engaged / appointed  to receive calls and responding calls. 
iii.  Copy of agreement signed with  that organization for management of
  call  centre  and amount fixed for this service.  
iv. Total  amount already released ( date –wise)  and  total  amount pending  to be released  to that organization.  
v. Details of
  procedure followed for  taking decision
  to engage that organization for COVID 19   CALL CENTRES.  
vi. Total calls
  received by Call centres ( date-wise) . | 
 RTI Application has been forwarded to the
  PIO, Dept. of E and IT  to provide  information.  But 
  we are  yet  to get the 
  information, though two months passed.  | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 20.5.20 | 
Doctors working with Govt. 
  1.Total
  No. of Doctors presently  working in
  Odisha govt. Contractual, regular, adhoc doctors wise 
  2.Provide  details of eligibly  criteria 
  fixed by Govt.  for the doctors  to receive    advance salary in view of corona.  
3. Provide  total no. of  doctors 
  already  provided  advance salary  declared 
  by  Govt.  till yet 
  and date  of  release 
  of salary  to their
  accounts  and  copy 
  of  the letter  issued 
  by Govt. for release   advance  salary 
  to the doctors.  | 
RTI Application has
  been  forwarded  to several 
  directorates  to  provide 
  information.  Information about
  total no. of doctors in place  and
  vacancy  has been supplied.  But rest 
  of information is yet to be supplied.  | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 14.5.20 | 
Management  of COVID-19 
  Activity  
   i. details
  of  procedure  followed for from  COVID-19 testing  to declaration of  findings of the testing and no. of COVID-19
  affected patients  by Govt. publicly.  
ii. details
  of  decision taken  to appoint Mr.  Subroto Bagchi as Spokesperson for COVID-19
  including copy of the filling noting .  
iii. name
  of the officers  who  finally decide  for disclosure  of information about COVID-19 affected
  patients and no. of patients 
  cured  and died.  
iv. list  of the 
  people  with their  address 
  who got  cure after  undergoing 
  treatments  | 
Information about appointment
  of Mr. Bagchi  as spokesman  for COVID 
  has been  provided. But rest of the
  information has been kept secret till yet.   | 
| 
Heath & Family
  Welfare  Dept. , RTI filed on 1.5.20 | 
On-line  Self-quarantine
  registration of  persons 
Provide   total  
  NO. of  persons  who 
  voluntarily  registered for  undergoing  
  self-quarantine in the  online
  system of the  Govt. ( date-wise )  
ii.
  Provide  name of the  persons 
  with their  address   date 
  of their   on-line registration
  for  self-quarantine in CD.    
iii. Provide
  name  of the organization  and officials managing on-line  self-registration system for quarantine.  
IV. If  a private 
  organization is managing, please 
  provide  copy of the letter  authorizing 
  that  organization to manage it
  , copy  of agreement signed  and total fund released to that
  organization  for it.  | 
 Though 3 
  months passed , not  a
  single  information has been supplied
  to me.  | 
| 
Information and Public
  Relation Department . RTI Was filed  on
  1.5.20  | 
Advertisement  and 
  financial  support  for advertisement  on COVID 19 
   
.   Provide  
  total    amount  earmarked for  sensitization progarmme/ advertisement  on COVID 19  
ii. Provide
  total amount  paid  to 
  Print media  for  advertisement / sensitization on COVID
  19  fro March to May 20. 
iii. Provide
  total amount  pending  to be 
  paid  to  Print media 
  for  advertisement /
  sensitization on COVID 19  from March
  to May 20. 
iv. Provide
  total amount  paid  to  
  each  electronics media    for 
  advertisement / sensitization on COVID 19  from March to May 20. 
v. Provide  total amount  pending to be  paid 
  to   each  electronics media ( state and national)     for 
  advertisement / sensitization on COVID 19  from March to May 20. 
vi. Provide total amount paid  English news papers  for advertisements on COVID  
vii. Provide amount paid  to 
  each print media  of outside state
  for advertisement on COVID 19  
viii. Provide total amount paid  to Sambad, Samaj , Prameya, Dharitri ,
  Pragatibadi  for advertisement on COVID
  19. 
IX. Provide total amount paid to any
  organization or other agency  on COVID
  19  | 
Though  3 months passed, the PIO  has kept 
  this  information  secret. Apprehending  public expose  of mega corruption in advertisement,
  this  information has been kept  secret 
  at  the  direction of  highest 
  authority of Mo Sarkar.  | 
| 
Dept. of General
  Administration and PG, Govt. of Odisha 
  RTI Filed  on 1.5.20  | 
Details  of  Arup Patnaik deputed  by Chief Secretary  to 
  Gujurat  to  look into 
  problem  of  Odia workers  in Surat 
i. Provide 
  copy  of the letter  of 
  Chief Secretary addressed  to
  Chief Secretary of  Got. Of
  Gujurat  about  Visit 
  of Arup Patnaik  to  look into look into  problem 
  of  Odia workers  in Surat. 
ii. Provide 
  details  of advance money , if
  any  released  to Arup patnaik  for 
  his visit  to Gujurat . 
iii. Provide 
  copy  of report, if any
  submitted  by Arup Patnaik  to Govt. of Odisha .  
iv. Provide 
  details of  bill  submitted 
  by Arup Patnaik  against  expenses made  in Gujurat.  | 
No  information has been  supplied till yet. However, first appeal
  has been  filed to get  the 
  information.  | 
| 
Bhubaneswar  Municipal Corporation. RTI Filed on 15.4.20 | 
  Details of
  allowances  paid  to  Vendors And Vending Zone  in Bhubaneswar 
.   Provide 
  list of details of Vending Zone and its  location 
  in Bhubaneswar along with 
  year  of constitution of  vending zone.  
ii.
  Provide  list  of 
  street vendors  identified  by BMC 
  in Bhubaneswar  in CD . 
iii.
  Provide  copy  of the  
  notification about  latest  formation of Vending Zone  Committee 
  by BMC  and its members . 
iv.
  Provide  copy  of proceedings  of Vending Zone Committee  meeting held  from 2014 
  to 2020.  
v. Provide 
  copy of the  circular/
  order  issued  by Govt. to give allowances  to vendors  due to COVID-19 emergency .  
vii. Provide   total amount  sanctioned to the BMC  for payment of allowances    to vendors. 
viii. Provide  list 
  of Vendors who have been paid 
  amount  by  the 
  BMC  | 
Though 3  months 
  passed, BMC has not 
  provided  a single  information till yet.  | 
| 
Information and  Public Relation Department. RTI filed  on 21.6.20  | 
Amount sanctioned   under  different 
  heads  for  the 
  people  engaged  for 
  preparation of  press note   on COVID-19 
i.  provide 
  details of  amount  sanctioned/ earmarked   or 
  budgetary  provision made
  under  different  heads 
  to meet  expenses  for the 
  people engaged for  preparation
  of  press  note on COVID-19  addressed by Mr. Subroto Bagchi  and 
  other officials.  
ii.
  Provide total  amount   already spent  under different heads  for 
  said  purpose ( month-wise) 
iii.
  Provide  details of expenses  made 
  for  organizing  press meet on COVID-19   held at Geet Govind Sadan.( daily).  
iv.
  Provide  name of the  private 
  organization / TV channel entrusted to 
  telecast the  programme,
  copy  of agreement  signed 
  with  it  and 
  total days  allotted  for the said work,  amount 
  earmarked  for  the said 
  work  and amount already
  paid  to this  organization with  date 
  of payments.  | 
Though 30 days 
  passed, the PIO has not supplied 
  any  information.  | 
| 
Department  of Panchayat Raj, Govt. of Odisha. RTI
  Filed  dt. 21.6.20  | 
Amount sanctioned  for  giving 
  incentive of Rs.2000.00  to
  the  people  after 
  completion  of their quarantine
  period.    
   i.
  Provide    total fund allocated   for 
  giving  incentive of
  Rs.2000.00  to the  people 
  after  completion  of their quarantine period.              
ii. Provide  total amount  received 
  from  CMRF for  giving 
  incentive of Rs.2000.00  to
  the  people  after 
  completion  of their quarantine
  period.              
iii. Provide  total fund 
  allotted  to each  district for 
  giving  incentive of
  Rs.2000.00  to the  people 
  after  completion  of their quarantine period.              
iv. Provide total  amount 
  of incentive  already  paid 
  in each  district  | 
Though 30 days 
  passed, the PIO  has not supplied
  any  information.  | 
| 
Dept. of Agriculture  and Farmers’ Empowerment, RTI was  filed on 14.5.20  | 
total no. of  list 
  of farmers  sent  to the Central Govt.  for financial assistance  under PM Kishan Scheme   
i.
  Provide  total no. of list  of 
  farmers   sent  to Central Govt. for financial assistance  under PM Kishan Scheme in different phases
  with date and copy of the  forwarding
  letter.  
ii.
  Provide  total no. of  list of 
  farmers sent  to Central Govt. for financial
  assistance  under PM Kishan Scheme in
  different phases ( district-wise).  
iii.
  Provide total  amount  of financial assistance  given 
  to  total  farmers 
  in Odisha  under PM Kishan
  scheme and  month  of payments.  
iv.  Provide 
  copy  of  all correspondence  made between  State 
  Govt. and Central  Govt. in
  respect of  payment  of financial assistance  under PM Kishan scheme upto May 2020.  | 
No 
  information has been  
  proved  till yet.  It has been 
   kept  secret 
  to cover up  irregularities.   | 
Pradip Pradhan 
M-9937843482
Date-2.8.20 
 
No comments:
Post a Comment